Saturday, 20 October 2012

Thoughts on visiting the cemeteries of The Great War

Panorama, Sunken Road Cemetery, Fampoux
Monday 8th October. 
A rainy mid-day, Sunken Road Cemetery, Fampoux, near Arras, listening to a description of the action that took place in the amphitheatre of fields in front, fierce fighting for the heavily defended village of Roeux and its chemical works - battles that raged throughout April and May 1917.  
Three specifics: 
First, the terrific experience of hearing the detail of a battle from such a vantage point. The terrain now looks so benign... and yet anyone with half an imagination will see far more than crops. And, of course, many of the men who fell in the action are here, below your feet. 
Second - the immaculate solemn beauty of this and indeed all the Commonwealth cemeteries. Their uniqueness. Large and small, every one is different. The planting - English country garden - roses, asters, lavender, you name it, it’s there. Tended with huge care and pride often by generations of the same family. 
Third - it was lunchtime. Some of us sat on the wall to eat their sandwiches. I had mine by the grave of a 20 year old, and texted my son, the same age, to tell him. He texted back, ‘Good stuff.’ 

Those three observations just about sum it up, for me. Carnage happened. The evidence is right here. Paying my respects is the least I can do, giving those who fell a little of what they had taken from them. Time.  
       What about the sandwiches? Isn’t that disrespectful? I don’t think so.

Before The Last Post, Menin Gate
 I am reminded of a  service of the Last Post under the Menin Gate at Ypres recently. 
        A wreath was laid by a young airman, and in support, a whole group, uniforms immaculate, marching in perfect order. To see the wreath laid, the last post ringing out, the young man snapping to attention and saluting before wheeling on his heel and returning to his comrades - was wonderful. As was the normality of passing them no more than six or seven minutes later, as, having marched  out of the Gate, they’d now relaxed. ‘Right, take me to the nearest pub,’ one said. ‘I need a drink....’ They all walked away chatting and joking, into the city.    

That’s about right. Job done. Life goes on, for some. To do otherwise is to try to make the men who fell into saints, when actually, weren’t they all ordinary blokes? Not saints at all. Respect is of course due in immeasurable quantities, but I get the sense that it is more than OK, as far as they would be concerned, for you to eat your sarnies alongside, bringing a sliver of the everyday to those who lost their everydays on our behalf. That is not overstating it, even nigh on a hundred years later. Britain would not exist were it not for the outcome of this war. Whatever one thinks of the strategists and their plans, every man who fell, named on a headstone or not, is part of the sometimes faltering juggernaut that ultimately crushed Germany. 
        I have a strong sense too, that it is important for women to visit. Important for the fallen, not us. This woman has many many roles - wife, mother, colleague, friend, writer, teacher, editor - as well as daughter of a much-missed decorated WW11 veteran - but when I’m there the most important role is that of a mother. Of sons. So in a sense, I’m not only there saying a quiet hello to the fallen, I’m also there for all the mothers who couldn’t go across to see where their lad was. For all the mothers who aren’t here any more. Maybe they know. Maybe not. That's OK.
Morval Cemetery
How do I feel after visiting the battlefields and cemeteries, six days on the Somme, Arras, then Ypres? Wrung out, still. But I think that’s natural. We talk about ‘paying’ our respects. This act is not cheap - it’s something that costs. Maybe it is the mix of response that is so exhausting. Sadness, for every single man who fell, for their families and friends. A determination that we who follow on must not forget. The deep peace of these places - every response builds into a mesh of emotion that is impenetrable at first. It lifts after time. 
         
 “Battlefields are one thing, cemeteries another. I wouldn’t bother with the cemeteries.” A quote, from someone gloriously unaware of the effect of what he was saying.  I was just sad for the speaker.  The effect was to shriek his ignorance. It was to reduce a battlefield visit to a disneyesque experience, sanitised and two-dimensional. You might as well draw up lines of opposing plastic soldiers on a model of the terrain, knock them over with pea-shooters in order of battle-history. 
           What did he think he would find in the cemeteries? I don’t know. But for my money he was ignoring some of the biggest reasons to go to the battlefields. Those reasons are not those things you can pick up in text books. To avoid visiting the cemeteries is not to allow yourself to be overwhelmed by many stark realities.  Not to allow yourself to feel. If we seek to protect ourselves from our feelings - and that may be one reason for my colleague ‘not bothering’ with the cemeteries - is that not a little dangerous?  
Asters, Essex Farm Cemetery, at the grave of Pte. E Wynne, Leinster Regiment.
 It is hard not to feel sadness standing by the grave of a lad who went to his death on the battlefield from a farm in Sussex, or a terrace in a Welsh valley town.  One of the realities of war is the vastness of the numbers. Vast numbers of graves of lads like this, headstones with names, dates, inscriptions.  Vast numbers of graves alongside, holding remains that were un-nameable. Name after name after name on the many memorials to the missing. 
          


Thiepval Memorial
We had an interesting difference of opinion on the Memorial to the Missing of the Somme at Thiepval. To many, it is the ultimate memorial, the best. Not to me. It is majestic, yes, overwhelming, yes - but it is something else. It sits astride the ridge like some gigantic alien, no lack of hubris, a definite air of triumphalism. It lacks beauty. Contrast it with the Canadian Memorial at Vimy Ridge, the Menin Gate at Ypres, Memorials to the Missing at Ploegsteert, at Arras, at Vis en Artois or Tyn Cot. There, beauty melds with sadness to produce an extraordinary, deep peacefulness. Thiepval holds no peace. It just shakes its fist at the world. I wonder whether the triumphalism of Thiepval might have been an additional thorn in Germany’s side during the mid 1930s...provocative? Who knows?
Langemark German Military Cemetery 
          
Visiting Langemark German cemetery is a very different experience to spending time in Commonwealth cemeteries. In comparison it is dark, stolid, Wagnerian in character.  At its heart is a mass grave holding some 25,000 soldiers, guys who, just like our own, fought for something they believed in, most of the time - you can’t forget that. There are also two British soldiers buried here, as there are often German soldiers buried in Commonwealth Great War cemeteries. My writer’s imagination with can’t help but create irreverent fictions in both settings - unsettled after-hours conversations. Black humour and war go hand in hand. It helps to salve the harshness.
           Apparently, some time into the war, our cinemas screened newsreel footage showing bodies on a battlefield. Beforehand, only ‘managed’ information had been screened - propaganda-led. Sanitised. There was uproar. ‘But people are dying...’. Well, yes. That’s what war does.
"Let me like a soldier fall..."

        Maybe at the tail end of the Victorian era with its predisposition to sentimentality, the lads now in these graves might have written letters home busting with sugary cliches, but meaning every single word. 

Then, they’d turn on the black humour and belt out trench songs they’d never in a million years sing in front of their mothers, giving a V sign to the reality they faced:

When old Jerry shells your trench, never mind
And your face may lose its smile, never mind
When the sandbags bust and fly, you have only once to die
If old jerry shells your trench, never mind
Under the Menin Gate- one of the many walls covered in names
 Here you go lads - a new verse or two:
When you get blown to bits, never mind
and your arse flies through your tits, never mind
If you make the Sargeant linger to pick up your little finger
When you get blown to bits, never mind

When you’re just a word at Wipers, never mind 
Bleedin’ bugles, bleedin’ pipers, never mind 
You’ll be so high up the wall, Mum won’t find your name at all,
when you’re just a name at Wipers, never mind

Tyn Cot, sundown

My 20 year old lunch partner at Sunken Lane was Private A Law, 47117, 10th Bn, West Yorkshire Regiment (Prince of Wales's Own). He died on 28/08/1917 and was the son of Alfred and Jane Elizabeth Law, of 53, Joicey St., Sherburn Hill, Durham. 




Writing this is akin to why I go - quite apart from finding the cemeteries and memorials to the missing deeply moving places, and feeling a strong sense of 'Be yerself Missis, that's all we want...' - each time I read a name or stand by a headstone saying ‘A Soldier of The Great War’ I am acknowledging that person existed and while he did, even if it was for a short time, he accomplished something far more extraordinary than I ever will.


Pics of Sunken Road Cemetery and Langemark German Military Cemetery are by Jeremy Banning.

14 comments:

  1. Thank you for your sensitive account. It's hard to add anything that wouldn't sound banal. I haven't ever been there but even TV footage of the cemeteries moves me beyond tears. To experience them personally would wring me out.

    Both my grandfathers came home alive but neither ever spoke of their experiences. One said, before turning away, 'You wouldn't want to know.'

    ReplyDelete
  2. With you at every step, Missis. 'I wouldn't bother with the cemeteries'? Good grief, they brought the equation full circle for me. There seems little point in seeing the battle sites if they're not followed up by a visit to the corresponding cemetery.

    For me, Thiepval was about its meaning, those endless names. I was dumbstruck before I went there, and absolutely floored by both the idea and the sight of it, as you know, but I do agree, the structure seems to be more about the architect and his vision than about its purpose. Having said that, a lot of people said they would count it as the place they found most moving.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Very moving piece, thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Lovely article. I just don't know how you can visit a battlefield and not visit a cemetery? It denies what war is about. My father fought in WWII and he is very sparing on the detail of war. It's not glorious.
    I found the cemetery at Langemark especially moving. There are very few visitors from Germany and it seems a much darker place than its Allied counterparts.The Last Post at the Menin Gates is an incredibly moving ceremony, the more so that it occurs every day.
    I'd recommend anyone to go if they can. It's challenging but I think you come away with a deep sense of gratitude to those that fought and died there and an appreciation for the peace in Europe we've experienced in our lifetime.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Sally - it is so poignant now, to look back on a generation who wanted to protect others from the detail of what they had been through. Bless them.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Zoe, it was great to have your company on the trip. Here's to next year. And yes - I remember seeing Thiepval for the first time, it was the first memorial to the missing Id seen - nothing to compare it with. I guess we all respond in different ways, and that is how it should be.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thanks for reading, womagwriter - all v best to you.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi Pete - very well said. I can imagine your own experiences of visiting, on bikes, must have been a very interesting one - very close to the terrain, in a way that we, in our people-carrier, weren't, most of the time. And yes - thank the lord for the EU.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I spend a lot of time at cemeteries, it will never be enough, I think, for the war dead. They never sleep.

    And so fitting, and touching, to share your sandwiches.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hi Rachel - they hold a special pull, don't they? Sarnies notwithstanding!

    ReplyDelete
  11. V,

    Some mates and I went on a very boozy cycle tour of Normandy a few years ago. Our route took us past one of the allied D-Day cemetries, so we popped in, on a whim, really. I can tell you, the five of us spent a very long time walking around among the graves. And I noticed that while we entered as a group, we soon separated and avoided each others' eyes as we looked about, read the carvings on the stones and the many, many news clips and bits and pieces that people – family? – had stuck to some of them. When we left, we were very quiet.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hi Neil - special places, aren't they? And extraordinary how different the Commonwealth Cemeteries are to the American, for example.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Very powerful stuff. I've spent a lot of time in Commonwealth cemeteries in Italy for translation work. It's heart-wrenching, especially being a mother of three sons. The trenches of the mountain campaigns were so desperately high, with cables for food and mule trails for transport, cardboard shoes and icy letters home. And howitzers with a range of 22kms!

    It must not be forgotten.

    ReplyDelete